Blog

Is The Rising of the Shield Hero worth reading?

The betrayed hero, the raccoon girl and the kingdom that framed him. What readers say about the Shield Hero novels, and where they say it sags.

What it is

Is The Rising of the Shield Hero worth reading, or is it an anime that happens to have books? The Rising of the Shield Hero (盾の勇者の成り上がり) started as a long Syosetu web novel. Naofumi Iwatani, a college student, is summoned to the kingdom of Melromarc as one of four Cardinal Heroes, and gets the shield, the one nobody wants. Within a day he's been robbed, framed and turned into the kingdom's villain. He buys a sick demi-human slave girl, Raphtalia, because a slave can't betray him, and the two of them start over from the bottom while the Waves of Catastrophe keep arriving. Bitter revenge fantasy at the start, party adventure later.

What readers love

The first volumes. Almost every review calls the opening arc the strongest in the genre: Naofumi's anger is written from the inside, Raphtalia's recovery is slow and earned, and the world hates him in specific ways. Readers also like that the shield forces him to fight sideways, with poison, trade, cooking and other people's swords. Raphtalia is the most loved character by a wide margin, and anime readers say the novel gives her fear and grief more room.

What divides them

Everything after the first four volumes. A common reading is that the series peaks with the church conspiracy and then loosens, adding party members and countries faster than it can use them. The three other heroes are the other complaint: readers want them to grow, they mostly don't, and some people quit out of irritation. The slave collar divides readers too, and the book's defense of it convinces some and not others. The One Peace Books translation reads plainly and gets called rough, and the web novel's Naofumi is nastier than the print one.

Is The Rising of the Shield Hero worth reading past the anime?

The first four volumes are worth anyone's time, which is rarer than it sounds. The book's trick is that Naofumi's paranoia is right and the reader knows it, so his cruelty reads as sense until Raphtalia makes it read as a wound. We're with the doubters on the middle, where the series invents new heroes and kingdoms as a way of not resolving the old ones. Readers who stop after the church arc remember the book fondly, which tells you something.

It's for readers who want a hero with a reason to be angry and a companion who deserves him, and not for anyone who needs a plan.

Based on reader reviews; we'll write our own once we've finished it.

If you enjoy it, support the author where it's published: Syosetu. Licensed English edition: One Peace Books.

Try Crossleaf. Bring a story in any language and read it in English, chapter by chapter, with the original a tap away. Start reading free →